There are various indicators for measuring the performance of national flags; this largely includes accidents, administrative burden and port detentions. Inspections of ships and crews are carried out by port state inspectors; this generally occurs on an ad hoc basis, with records being kept by the inspection authority concerned. In the Netherlands, these inspections are the responsibility of the Dutch Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate.
Worldwide inspection data are used to generate performance rankings of the national flags. The best known of these is the Paris MoU (Memorandum of Understanding), which ranks countries on data from the previous three years. The more detentions a flag has, the lower that flag will be in the rankings table. The Netherlands currently holds fourth place in the Paris MoU white list – an excellent position!
The Paris MoU is just one example; there are many other MoUs around the world. These also comprise the inspection results from their own Port State Controls, using the following numbers:
- Number of inspected vessels
- Number of shortcomings
- Number of detentions
White, grey, and black lists
Based on inspection result data, flag states and classification societies are classified into white, grey or black lists. The white list contains the best performers, and the black list contains the poorest performers.
In 2017, the Dutch flag received the following number of detentions:
Memorandum of understanding
|
Number of detentions 2017
|
Paris MoU
|
14
|
Tokyo MoU
|
4
|
Viña del Mar
|
0
|
Carribean MoU
|
0
|
Med MoU
|
1
|
Indian Ocean MoU
|
2
|
Abuja MoU
|
0
|
Black Sea MoU
|
2
|
Riyadh MoU
|
0
|
USCG
|
0
|
Total
|
22
|
Paris MoU ranking
Considering the Paris MoU rankings of flag states, the KVNR strives that the Dutch flag holds a top-ten position in the white list. After a number of years of lower scores, this was achieved in 2017 – meaning that the Dutch flag is once again one of the best quality registers.
With detention figures of just 1.4 per cent, the Dutch flag performed better than average in the Paris MoU in 2017 (average detention figures = 3.84 per cent).
The table below shows the Paris MoU data for the Dutch flag over the last three years.
Paris MoU – Dutch flag
|
2015
|
2016
|
2017
|
Number of inspections
|
1038
|
992
|
999
|
Number of deficiences
|
1387
|
1394
|
1422
|
- ISM deficiencies
|
51
|
48
|
53
|
Number of detentions
|
10
|
11
|
14
|
detention ratio
|
0,96%
|
1,1%
|
1,4%
|
White List position of The Netherlands
|
12
|
4
|
3
|
The position in the rankings table is calculated by comparing a country’s average inspection data from the last three years with the averages of the other flag states. Due to its excellent performance since 2015, the Dutch flag took 3rd place in 2017 – an impressive result!